We’re all connoisseurs of something. For some folks, their knowledge and obsession is linked with fine dining or travel, but for those of us that are far more refined, we are horror movie aficionados. As experts in all things spooky, jump-scary, or generally evil, horror movie fans are a special breed of human. We live for Halloween but don’t limit ourselves to a single season of spookiness. We watch scary movies all year and therefore, have the sophistication to weigh in on our favorites.

So whether you’re a pro or someone simply looking to the Internet to find a scary movie to watch tonight, this list is straight from the mouths of those who know what they’re talking about. Possessions, slashers, and Darth Maul wannabe’s lie ahead, so ye be warned. All who dare scroll onward are at risk of getting a heart flutter, stomach drop, and some serious nightmare fuel.