If you ever wondered why babies look old in ancient paintings, here’s why
You’re travelling, having a good time, and you decide to visit a local museum and check out a medieval exhibition. You wander through the gallery a little bit, then get stuck for half an hour staring at a painting of baby Jesus, wondering why he looks like a forty-five-year-old accountant who’s been through three divorces and a mortgage.
Now you’re hooked; you are ashamed to pull out your cellphone and do a quick ChatGPT-powered search because you don’t want to look like an iPad kid at the art museum, but you confront your fears and do it anyway. Suddenly, you find out why, you feel like an art expert, and the nugget of wisdom becomes your new favourite party trick.
Medieval artists weren’t necessarily trying to make babies look realistic or work within anatomical parameters. Instead, they were working within an artistic tradition that prioritised symbolism, meaning, and theological ideas over anatomical accuracy.
This tradition was accentuated even more when artists were depicting baby Jesus, basically because of his importance. Obviously, he wasn’t just like any other baby for the medieval painters. He was believed to be the incarnation of the Divine and possessed eternal wisdom from the very beginning of his life, and that’s why he had to be depicted accordingly.
So painting him with the proportions and features of an adult man had the purpose of communicating that he had the wisdom of an old man from the moment he was born.
Art historians often describe this approach as ‘the homuncular infant’.
Of course, baby Jesus wasn’t the only one who was depicted like this, and while it’s very tempting to assume medieval people didn’t recognise infancy as a distinct stage of life, we know they did. They knew infants weren’t the same as adults; the age depicted on their faces in portraits was intended to communicate social status rather than actual age.
For centuries, many artists relied on historical tradition and learned from existing patterns and models; if it wasn’t for the Renaissance and its interest in anatomical models, we’d still see old children every time we walked into a museum.
That isn’t necessarily bad thoug, I think it’s an interesting way to step out of realism without jumping into more abstract currents like cubism, but anyway, do you think this style is making a comeback this season?
Just kidding, enjoy your classical, weekly meme list!